Golf GTI49/70
The Deal
7
Around $19k for a Mk7.5 with the Performance Package. VW depreciation is steeper than the Japanese rivals.
The Drive
6
Torquey, refined, endlessly easy to drive fast. Front-wheel drive, so muscle and polish rather than rotation.
The Upkeep
7
Cheaper to run than the rear-drive V6s: better mpg, smaller tires, moderate insurance. VW service is the premium.
The Risk
6
The plastic water pump and thermostat housing is the near-certain repair, around $900. A cluster, not a catastrophe.
The Daily
9
A 9, level with the Golf R. Four doors, a real back seat, more cargo than most crossovers.
The Limit
6
The VAQ diff genuinely helps, but front-wheel drive caps engagement at the edge. Fun, not thrilling.
The Mods
8
A $700 flash adds 50 to 70 hp. The IS20 turbo caps it below a Golf R, but the value is elite.